Best Pet Supply Store: Agri-Feed Pet Supply

Best Pet Supply Store Runners-Up: Active Pets, Critter Barn, Shane's Pick-A-Critter

What this suggests is that pets vote. Agri-Feed is enormous, and at a glance its interior might be mistaken for that of a loss-leader box store near the interstate. Then you realize that they don't stock "everything for your pet." They only stock things that are good for your pet. Between their customer rewards program, the expert customer service, and the pet-love karma you'll receive in the next life, you're golden like a retriever.